Skip to content
Home » Briefing Series » Can The Economy Grow Forever?

Can The Economy Grow Forever?

Briefing Series: Planetary Boundaries

Note: Click here for a one-page PDF version. Web version last updated on 20th January 2026.

Background

  • The Planetary Boundaries framework, widely used in sustainability, economics and earth-system science (1) (2), simply states:
    • Within planetary boundaries humanity can operate safely.
    • Beyond these limits, the planet’s natural resilience is weakened.
  • As seen in the graphic, scientific assessment indicates that seven of nine planetary boundaries have now been crossed (3).
  • These include biodiversity, climate change, freshwater change and land system change.

Source: Stockholm Resilience Centre

Why does this matter to Ireland?

  • The government seems to assume that economic growth can continue indefinitely (4).
  • Are they aware that economic growth has historically been linked to increasing energy usage and material throughput?
  • Increasing energy usage and material throughput equals greater environmental pressures (5).
  • As the EPA has noted: “Arresting growth in emissions is a challenge in … a growing economy….” (6)
  • Indeed, despite decades of investment and effort, 90% of natural habitats in Ireland are in an ‘unfavourable’ condition (7) and progress on greenhouse gas emissions has been limited (8).

What questions need to be asked?

  • Can an economy grow forever within finite ecological limits?
  • If Yes: What evidence supports this?
  • If No: What types of economic activity are compatible with long-term well-being?
  • Indeed, what types of economic activity need to be reduced or phased out?
  • What would Ireland look like if it were operating within ecological limits?
  • Given the polluter-pays principle, who should pay for any EU fines for failure to cut emissions?

Further exploration

Awareness of the Planetary Boundaries framework in Ireland

Awareness of either the framework or the nine boundaries seems to be poor with the bulk of government thinking and public communication focused on a single planetary boundary, namely “Climate Change”.

This is evident from a Google search of the EPA.ie website on 19 January 2026 for the seven boundaries that have been crossed (site:epa.ie plus search string inside quote signs. E.g. site:epa.ie “Climate Change”):
Climate Change: +/-12,400 results
Ocean acidification: 117 results
Freshwater change: 0 results
Land system change: 2 results
Biogeochemical flows: 0 results
Novel entities: 5 results
Biosphere integrity: 2 results

We also ran the same query of the RTE.ie website:
Climate Change: +/-12,600 results
Ocean acidification: 66 results
Freshwater change: 0 results
Land system change: 0 results
Biogeochemical flows: 0 results
Novel entities: 1 result
Biosphere integrity: 0 results

A search for the term “planetary boundaries” returned:
EPA.ie:  63 results. The term “planetary boundary” was found 591 times.
RTE.ie: 10 results.